troopers matters2

Early Stage Valuations

HOW EARLY IS TOO EARLY?

The question is: how can we evaluate the startup if we have not yet reached the stage where recurring revenues are the norm?

Early-stage startups are usually evaluated with qualitative approaches as we do not have a lot of quantitative data available. In this article, we will cover the most common qualitative/early-stage valuation methods. As always we value your feedback. Let us know which of these you have used in the past!

First a small disclaimer: Whilst valuation methods normally have a rather thorough and extensive history in academic publications, qualitative valuations do not. The following methods find their roots more in industry practices, than in actual valuation theory.

The Scorecard Method

The scorecard method was conceived by William H. Payne of Ohio TechAngels group when he faced the decade old question on how to value early-stage businesses. The valuation of the company depends on how its characteristics differ from the average of comparable companies. 

Different markets and different ecosystems have different levels of valuations, and this method takes into account different geographic benchmarks. The qualitative traits of each start-up are divided into 6 criteria and then they are given a score, in percentage, according to whether they are better or worse than the average company.

The Checklist Method

The creator of this method is David W. Berkus, one of the most prominent Californian angel investors and venture capitalists. The checklist method uses building blocks that sum up to a maximum pre-money valuation.

This maximum is composed of 5 different criteria that are weighted differently according to their importance. The company is awarded portions of these maximum criteria valuations according to how close its qualitative traits are to the most desirable ones. These values are then compared to the benchmark valuation in the analysed market.

troopers matters2

The Dilutive Method

The dilutive method helps to understand which percentage of the company investors will likely require in order to deploy the requested funds.

The dilutive method is not a methodology meant to pinpoint an accurate valuation, but it’s a tool that finds its usefulness in understanding which percentage of the company investors will likely require in order to deploy the requested funds. In this sense, this technique is totally dependent on the round size and, for venture or growth investments, normally ranges anywhere between 10% and 30%.

The VC Method

The Venture Capital Method, or VC method, is one of the most common approaches when valuing early-stage companies. How this works is by figuring out the return that an investor wants, in order to deploy cash into the business. 

The company will have a valuation that is therefore consistent with a predetermined return at the exit. The potential exit value is derived from the specific EV/EBITDA multiple of the benchmarked market. The final valuation equals this exit value discounted by a required return on investment (ROI). 

This depends on a number of factors, including the startup’s stage of development, as well as the kind of investors that might invest in the company. This method relies on both market multiples and the income a specific company will likely generate in the future and it could be considered both a Market and Income-based method.

OUR METHOD

We at Matters2 use a blend of 5 different methods (5+1 to be precise), and we modulate their weights according to the company’s stage… Want to know more? We can do a 3rd party valuation for you – no problem! Feel free to reach out any time 🙂

Early Bird Matters2

SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEWSLETTER
TO RECEIVE UPDATES ON NEW ARTICLES

Website's Newsletter Form
Cake Matters2

Slicing The Pie

When it comes to your start-up, you want to ensure complete equality of equity. Finances are of the utmost importance, and it's essential you find a way of fairly and impartially determining…
Crowdfunding Video ok Matters2

The Crowdfunding Video

Crowdfunding: you put together a video, ready to let your idea off into the investment stratosphere. But what goes in the video?
Anti-Funnel Matters2

The Anti-Funnel

We know we could have a bigger mailing list if we had put our downloads behind a paywall, but we like to do things differently here. What’s the catch? That’s the point,…
pessimism and optimism matters2

The Optimist/Pessimist Founder

If you are embarking on a new start-up project, one of the most useful things you can do is trying to control your positive/negative outlook on the world. Both attitudes can help…
Scary Halloween Matters2

5 Spooky Innovations That Monetise Death

To celebrate the spooky season - but also because we just like the weird and creepy things - we thought it would be great to look into some "horrific" startups and companies…
Solo Founders Matters2

Solo Founders: Myths and Legends

When you’re setting out into the world of business, some widely accepted wisdom states that you need a business partner. After all, starting a company is tough, and you need all the…

SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEWSLETTER
TO RECEIVE UPDATES ON NEW ARTICLES

Website's Newsletter Form

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.Required fields are marked *